Unfurling The Scroll

READING BETWEEN THE LINES OF ESTHER'S STORY


March 9, 2017

Wisdom of Hindsight

Shaina Rosenfeld

A careful reading of the Megillah tells us that what takes just a few minutes to retell actually took place over the span of a decade.  The Purim story begins with a 180-day party in celebration of the “third year of [Ahasuerus’s] rule.” The party is then extended for seven days and all inhabitants of Shushan are invited as well. Like proper citizens of the capital, the Jews want to join. When Mordechai warns against it, the community, as always, has those who heed the warning and those who disregard it. From Vashti’s death until Esther’s crowning  there is a span of several years as the king’s messengers search for an appropriate replacement. This is followed by yet another year of searching when Esther refuses to reveal her origins. Only then is Haman eventually promoted viceroy. And still, we are five years into the timeline, and less than three chapters deep in the Megillah! 

The events from the middle of the third chapter of the Megillah--when Haman finally acted on his burning jealousy and anger at Mordechai and his people--until the Purim celebration in Shushan towards the end of the 9th chapter, took place during one very tense year: “In the 12th year of the reign of Ahasuerus.” Five long years after Esther’s appointment. 

Had we been living at the time, it would have never occurred to most of us to draw parallels that seem so obvious today. Would we draw parallels to events 10 years prior to understand the chain of events? As Mordechai tells Esther, “Perhaps it is for such a time that you achieved royalty.” Could we see that six years down the line, Esther forcibly becoming Queen was not just fortuitous but divinely orchestrated? 

I often think about the story’s  title telling us the lesson we must learn as we try to live the story as it happens now. The hebrew words Megillat Esther are mutually contradictory. Megillah has the Hebrew root of  gilui--revelation--while Esther is from the word hester--hidden. The story we read is also full of innate intrigue and time lapses, of dreams and thoughts of the main players that no one else but an Omniscient G-d can know of. 

There is much to this world we cannot see the purpose or meaning of. So much is hidden from us--Esther, locked away in a castle with a maniacal despot. But our journey, our reading of this story, needs to come as a Megillah, as a revelation of the hidden layers. Then we do not understand meaning and purpose only in hindsight but can slowly discover it and use it to inform our actions and propel us forward in the present. 

Then, we truly are not reading the Megillah as if it has happened in the past. 

Shaina Rosenfeld grew up the daughter of Chabad representatives in Hamilton, Ontario. Today, she and her husband continue the work her parents began. Shaina is executive director and program coordinator of Chabad Lubavitch of Hamilton and the Beit Menachem Jewish Student Centre serving the Jewish students at McMaster University.

Cosmic Destiny 

Rochel Baila Yaffe

The Jews gathered in their cities throughout the provinces of King Ahasurusto attack those who sought to harm them. No man stood in their way, for fear of them had fallen upon all the nations.     (Esther, 9:2)

And he sent letters to all the Jews, to the one hundred and twenty-seven provinces of Ahasurus's kingdom, words of peace and truth, [instructing them] to observe these days of Purim on their proper dates, in the manner established for them by Mordechai the Jew and Queen Esther, just as they had accepted upon themselves and upon their descendants the observance of the fasts and their lamentations.      (Esther, 9: 30-31)

And the word of Esther confirmed the observances of these Purim days, and [the story] was inscribed in the book.    (Esther, 9:32)

Torah is the original hyperlinked text: the language used in one section can serve as a portal to other areas which use the same language. Far from a coincidence, such a parallel helps to illuminate a deeper message that is not readily apparent. This is true in particular for Megillat Esther (the Scroll of Esther) as it was written in a manner that conceals G-d’s presence.  Many areas of the Megillah echo not only the sentiment, but even the exact language, of other parts of the Torah such as the stories of Joseph and Daniel. I believe there is a connection between the above-quoted verses and a section of the Book of Jeremiah. By connecting these two texts, we discover that Queen Esther has nurtured a hope and vision that extended far beyond her—and the Jewish people’s—immediate safety and prosperity.

The Megillah concludes with a seemingly anticlimactic description of Esther and Mordechai attempting to establish Purim as a holiday for future generations. The Talmud (Tractate Megillah 7a) clarifies what this entails: recording the Purim story on parchment (like the other books of the written Torah), including it in the canon of Tanach, and reading this megillah annually. Esther, the Talmud relates, asks the Sages, to “write me and establish me.” This is the “word of Esther” that “confirmed the observances” and what was “inscribed in the book (see above verse 31).” Esther seems to place herself squarely in the middle of the narrative.

Rashi, the medieval commentator on Torah and Talmud, finds it necessary to elaborate on the Talmudic “write me and establish me”: he adds the words, “so it should be for me a name.” This phrase, desiring a name for oneself, connotes self-centeredness, as evidenced by another place in the Torah which uses  a similar phrase—the generation of the Tower of Babel. Those wicked people strove to overtake and conquer G-d, as it were. Why would Rashi tack on this phrase and negatively color Esther’s motivation?

The answer lies in still another Torah “link” to this unusual phrase: in the book of Jeremiah, when the prophet describes the Jews’ ultimate return to the land of Israel. Jeremiah lived through the destruction of the First Holy Temple in Jerusalem, and he prophesied about the Jews once more returning and establishing a permanent home for G-d on earth. These verses uncannily mirror the abovementioned verses from the Megillah:

I have hidden My face from this city because of all their evil. Behold, I will bring it healing and cure, and I will cure them, and I will reveal to them a greeting of peace and truth. And I will return the captivity of Judah and the captivity of Israel, and build them up like at first. And I will purify them of all their iniquity that they sinned against Me, and I will forgive all their iniquities that they sinned against Me and that they rebelled against Me. And it shall be to Me for a name of joy, for praise and for glory to all the nations of the earth who will hear all the good that I do for them and fear and tremble because of all the good and because of all the peace that I do for it…the sound of mirth and the sound of joy, the voice of a bridegroom and the voice of a bride, the sound of those saying, "Thank the Lord of Hosts, for the Lord is good, for His loving-kindness endures forever," bringing a thanksgiving offering to the House of the Lord, for I will restore the captivity of the land as at first, said the Lord. (Jeremiah, 33:5-11)

Esther’s request to the Sages is not merely for a record of a local, limited victory over enemies and sanctification of G-d’s name. She sees the links to the cosmic destiny of the Jewish people, for their ultimate salvation from all evil in their return to the safety and holy dwelling of Israel with (she hopes) the complete redemption of the Jewish people.

Rochel Baila Yaffe, a graduate of Barnard College and mother of seven, co-directs Chabad of the Shoreline with her husband Yossi and teaches Judaic studies at Southern Connecticut Hebrew Academy.

Submit a comment


1000 characters remaining.
Chabad Lubavitch Worldwide

Candle Lighting Times


If you do not provide a specific location, the system will select an address nearest the center of whatever town, city, region or postal code you provide.
Share

Lubavitch International

Lubavitch International